A cash-secured put and a put spread both make money when the price stays above a level. They differ in what happens when it does not. This article puts numbers on that difference: how much each can earn, how much each can lose and how much capital each ties up. All figures are invented for the example.
The two trades
Say an ETF trades at $510. In the cash-secured put you sell one 500 put for $6.00 and set aside the cash to buy 100 shares at $500 if you are assigned. In the put spread you sell the same 500 put for $6.00 and also buy a 495 put for $4.80, so you receive a net credit of $1.20. The bought put is the protection: it is what puts a ceiling on the loss. The mechanics of the spread are in the bull put spread explained.
Maximum gain, maximum loss, capital
| Per contract | Cash-secured put | Put spread |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum gain | $600 | $120 |
| Maximum loss | $49,400 (price goes to zero) | $380 |
| Capital set aside | about $49,400 | $380 (the maximum loss) |
The spread maximum loss is the width of the spread minus the credit: ($5.00 − $1.20) × 100 = $380. The cash-secured put maximum loss is the strike minus the credit, times 100, if the price fell to zero. That is unlikely, but it is the number that defines the risk. Brokers may ask for different amounts of margin, so check yours.
Free one-page checklist (read the signal, check the trend filter, size by maximum loss, place the order and set the exits), plus the 20-page SPY Put Spread Playbook (PDF) in your welcome email.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What happens at three prices at expiry
| Price at expiry | Cash-secured put | Put spread |
|---|---|---|
| $510 or higher | +$600 | +$120 |
| $480 | −$1,400 | −$380 |
| $450 | −$4,400 | −$380 |
When nothing goes wrong, the put earns five times more. When the price falls sharply, the put keeps losing while the spread stops at $380. The spread gives up part of the gain to buy a limit on the loss. Whether that is worth it depends on how much loss you can accept on a single trade.
Why this matters when you size a trade
With the spread you know the worst case before you enter, so you can decide how many contracts fit your account. With the put the worst case depends on the price going to zero, and in a fast fall the loss can arrive before you can react. We explain our own choice in why defined risk matters. How to turn the maximum loss into a number of contracts is in how to size a put spread by its maximum loss.
What to check before choosing
- The loss you can accept on one trade, in dollars, not in percent of the credit.
- The capital each version ties up and what else that capital could do.
- Assignment: with the put you may end up owning 100 shares you must pay for.
- Costs: two options legs mean two commissions and two bid-ask spreads.
To see how this plays out on real signals, every closed trade of our paper-trading record is on the performance page. It is a short, early record, with option prices estimated by a model.
Educational content, not financial advice. Options trading involves significant risk of loss, including the loss of the whole amount at risk on a trade. All figures are made-up examples, and past and simulated results do not guarantee future performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a cash-secured put and a put spread? +
Both sell a put. The put spread also buys a put at a lower strike, which caps the loss at the spread width minus the credit. The cash-secured put has no such cap, so its worst case is much larger and needs much more capital set aside.
Which has the higher maximum loss? +
The cash-secured put: if the price went to zero the loss would be the strike minus the credit, times 100. In our example that is $49,400 against $380 for the spread.
Does a put spread always make less money? +
When the price stays above the short strike, yes: the credit is smaller because you pay for the bought put. You trade part of the gain for a limit on the loss.