A put spread has a defined maximum loss, so why use a stop at all? Because the maximum loss is large compared with the credit, and waiting for it is rarely what you want. This article explains the 1.5x stop used in FIREDesk signals with the arithmetic, the logged results and the main weakness.
How to read the FIREDesk numbers in this article. They come from our paper-trading record (14 May to 9 Oct 2026): no real capital was used, option prices are estimated by a model rather than taken from real fills, and 13 of the 102 logged signals use credits calibrated from historical data. The model has no sudden jumps in volatility, so real fills and real stops would be less favourable. On 12 October 2026 we also fixed a calculation error that had recorded stop-losses the market prices did not justify; the figures here are the corrected ones. It is a short, early record and it is not a forecast. Full detail is on the performance page.
The rule and the arithmetic
You sell a spread for a credit C per share. The stop closes the trade when buying the spread back costs 1.5 times C. The loss is then 1.5C - C = 0.5C, half the credit. The take profit sits at 0.5C of gain, so the payoff on the credit is roughly one to one.
- Example from the log: on 4 September 2026 the 725/715 put spread was sold for $0.72. The stop was $1.08. It triggered on 15 September, and the loss was ($1.08 - $0.72) x 100 x 4 contracts = $144.
- Held to expiry in the worst case the same position could lose ($10 - $0.72) x 100 x 4 = $3,712.
What 30 logged stops looked like
- 14 of 84 closed trades hit the stop. Losses ranged from -$138 to -$202 and averaged -$163, against an average winner of +$229. The stops came in clusters (7 of the 14 closed between 8 and 12 June), because positions opened in the same weeks share the same market move.
- Stops were held a median of 15 days, within a range of 8 to 42 days.
- By month of closing: June 10 stops, July 11, August none, September 9.
FIREDesk paper record, 14 May to 9 Oct 2026
- 102 signals logged: 84 closed (70 hit the 50% take profit, 14 hit the stop) and 18 still open.
- Average winning trade +$229, average losing trade -$163 (4 contracts, $10-wide spreads), profit factor 7.0.
- Total paper P&L on the closed trades: +$13,767, with a maximum drawdown of $1,038 (by closing date).
Stops cluster. They came in two groups of weeks, not spread evenly, because positions opened around the same time react to the same market move. If you run several spreads, one bad week can trigger several stops together.
Free one-page checklist (read the signal, check the trend filter, size by maximum loss, place the order and set the exits), plus the 20-page SPY Put Spread Playbook (PDF) in your welcome email.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
The weakness: how the stop is filled
In paper trading the stop is assumed to execute at the trigger price, which is why no stop lost more than about $202. In a real account the spread price can jump past your level in a fast market, the bid/ask gets wider, and the fill can be worse than planned. A real loss on a stopped spread can therefore exceed half the credit. Never size a position on the assumption that the stop will always fill at its level.
What stopping costs you
- Some stopped trades would have recovered. You lock in the loss in exchange for removing the large one.
- Every closing order has commissions and slippage, which matter more on small credits.
- Stops tie your results to short-term moves, so your win rate falls compared with holding to expiry. That is the trade for a smaller worst case.
Alternatives, with no free lunch
- A wider stop (for example 2x the credit): fewer stops, larger loss each time.
- A stop on SPY (for example a close below the short strike): ignores the spread price, depends on the strike distance.
- No stop, small size: accept the defined maximum loss and make it small enough to live with.
Whatever you choose, size by the maximum loss of all open positions together. The related rule on the profit side is in the 50% take-profit rule, and the whole system is in the complete SPY bull put spread strategy guide.
Educational content, not financial advice. Options trading involves significant risk of loss, including the loss of the whole amount at risk on a trade. Past and simulated results do not guarantee future performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a 1.5x stop loss on a put spread? +
You close the spread when buying it back costs 1.5 times the credit you received, which makes the loss half the credit.
How many stops did the FIREDesk paper record have? +
14 of 84 closed trades hit the stop, with losses between -$138 and -$202 and an average of -$163, against an average winner of +$229.
Can a stop lose more than planned? +
Yes. In a fast market the spread can gap past the stop price and fill worse. Paper results assume the stop fills at its level, real trading does not guarantee that.